Finding myself 2000 miles from Montana but with a couple of boys who want to go fishing, we ventured into the brown waters of the Shenandoah River. This is, according to John Denver, “almost heaven.” He was, after all, singing about West Virginia, the Blue Ridge Mountains, and the Shenandoah River. I packed my fly rod and the boys brought their bait-casters.

The sun was sinking, the sky was clear, and slow-moving water tugged gently as we waded in. The boys started with some lures from a tackle box inherited from their grandfather who lived and fished in North Carolina: plugs, treble hooks, and fluorescent worms. Not a fly to be seen. They soon abandoned that tack when my youngest spotted the crayfish in the shallows. From then on they caught small crayfish, put them on their hooks, and threw the bait out to the fish.

With the boys set up, I threaded my line. Earlier in the day an older gentleman had told me that a Woolly Bugger would work in these waters, so I put a version of this classic onto my line. It had been tied by a guy manning a booth at a fish rodeo in the mountains of northern Georgia. Like the name suggests, it was big, black, and hairy. I tossed the line and stood watching the fly drift on the surface like a big black piece of fish food. I looked down. Standing thigh-deep, I could barely make out my feet. Certainly not the clear water I grew up around. But it wasn’t nearly as cold, either. And that cold, clear water was not here, but I was.

Bam! A fish hit my fly. My rod bent, my heart jumped, and then the fish jumped too. I brought him toward me, and he jumped again. It was a small-mouth bass. Not huge, but a good fighter and plenty fun to catch.

The moon rose early, while the western sky was still glowing. In the dusk, I glanced back toward shore. My youngest was on his hands and knees in the shallows stalking crayfish. Intent on his pursuit, he was happy and oblivious to anything beyond his present satisfaction. The moon reflecting on the water cast a pale yellow path along the dark river.

No, this isn’t Montana. But it is a good place nevertheless. Each place, I suppose, has a beauty all its own. But beauty requires eyes to see. It requires a willingness to submit to standards and conditions beyond my control or creation. Perhaps the good things of this world simply require the humility to see beyond my own expectations and my own demands.

It’s not easy to live fully in the present or fully in a particular place. Our lives tend to be split into many fragments, our attention bifurcated between a world of perpetual possibility and a world of concrete actuality. Yet it is only the latter where truly human lives are lived. The temptation is great to live in abstractions and possibilities, yet the crayfish are only caught in that particular pool, and the woolly bugger must be flipped into a particular eddy. And a boy’s excited voice when he sings out “I’ve got one” is precious to a Dad who needs constant reminding that the best things in life are right here, right now.




Previous articleWhy We Consent to the Wholesale Destruction of Good Land
Next articleCreative Destruction and its Benefits, China-Style
Mark T. Mitchell
Mark T. Mitchell teaches political theory at Patrick Henry College in Purcellville, VA. He is the author Michael Polanyi: The Art of Knowing and The Politics of Gratitude: Scale, Place, and Community in a Global Age (Potomac Books, 2012). He is co-editor of another book titled, The Humane Vision of Wendell Berry. Currently he is writing a book on private property. In 2008-9, while on sabbatical at Princeton University, he and Jeremy Beer hatched a plan to start a website dedicated to political decentralism, economic localism, and cultural regionalism. A group of like-minded people quickly formed around these ideas, and in March 2009, FPR was launched. Although he was raised in Montana and still occasionally longs for the west, he lives in Virginia with his wife, three sons and one daughter where they are in the process of turning a few acres into a small farm. See books written by Mark Mitchell.


  1. Excellent. I had some good luck with a woolly bugger this weekend fishing for skipjacks and trout in west central Alabama. Your final line rings true, and is reminiscent of Berry’s “Wild Geese.” Very nice.

  2. the best things in life are right here, right now.

    Yes! In this place, and this time, and no others. Other places and other times have their own best things, but not this one. One of the great tragedies of modern life is the expense spent on trying to make sure every best thing will be available wherever you are, whenever you want it. But that just isn’t the case. Beautiful short essay, Mark!

Comments are closed.