We write as two professors of public health who yearn for a better orientation to our work. After learning about the passing of the agrarian writer, poet, and essayist Wendell Berry, one of us immediately wrote to the other, “We need Berry. Right now, especially.”
Berry would not think too fondly of what modern public health has become: an overdependence on statistical methods of knowing and acting, a workforce which often presumes that those most equipped for the work must have several letters after their name, attempts to improve the health of the public through bureaucratic programming at a distance, and an epistemic bias that prioritizes technical knowledge in a professional’s head over the relationships and care fostered by the amateur. For much of our careers, Berry’s writings have haunted our thoughts and actions. For those with eyes to see and ears to hear, he has been a fly in the ointment of our profession and a voice calling us to a better way. (One of us has long considered placing The Art of the Commonplace in the mailboxes of fellow faculty members. Perhaps now is the time to do so.)
For we who have dedicated our careers to public health, there is no more devastating line to read than the opening line of “Health is Membership”: “From our constant and increasing concerns about health, you can tell how seriously diseased we are.” The great paradox is that talking about health without the proper relational context can actually contribute to our shared illnesses. Berry suggests our thinking about health must be within the activity of concrete communities, for genuine health is born out of “the sense of belonging to others and to our place; it is an unconscious awareness of community, of having in common.” It is an odd thing, Berry might say, to speak about rates of diabetes without immediately discussing the entire local food system—networks of farmers, grocery store owners, and families—which contribute to and can contend with those rates; or to debate interventions aimed at decreasing rates of opioid dependency without considering how those who suffer from opioid dependency can be better understood and cared for by those in their neighborhood or at their church.
We believe Berry would be proud of the story of Lillie B. Hall, as told within Dr. Wylin Wilson’s Womanist Bioethics: Social Justice, Spirituality, and Black Women’s Health. After her retirement from nursing in the early twenty-first century, Ms. Hall founded the Tuskegee Area Diabetes Support Group within her local church to help individuals manage their chronic illness. According to Wilson, support group meetings would feature “accessible presentations by physicians, dietitians, podiatrists, ophthalmologists, biologists, pastoral counselors, and many others who present on disease management and preventative care in ways that address the whole person—mind, body, and spirit.” Many from the surrounding region would go even though they themselves did not have diabetes, a practical implication of Hall’s philosophy that “when one person has diabetes, their family has diabetes, their church has diabetes, and their community has diabetes.”
Likewise, Berry’s account of health and community is evident in the work of Uplift Appalachia, a non-profit organization in eastern Tennessee which, among other programs, transports individuals who struggle with addiction to job interviews, career training, recovery housing, court appearances, probation meetings, and medical appointments. Importantly, the stated goal of this program is not merely to transport people to the manifold and interconnected resources they need, but to invite them into a deeper community with the local church.
To speak about health as such—that is, divorced from a particular community of people responsible for the cultivation of health—cannot help but introduce division, which is itself the hallmark symptom of disease. Berry shows us, time and time again, that the fundamental unit of health is neither the atomized individual nor the abstract public, but the community, “a place and all its creatures.” Berry’s health is incomplete without attending to the conditions of his family, the farm on which he labors, the citizens of Port Royal to whom he dedicated so much of his energy, and all the richness of the connections between these beings. And so, it must be for all of us—at least insofar as it’s the health of human persons (and not machines) that we’re interested in.
To consider the community as the fundamental unit of health is a serious charge for a profession that speaks so much about the health of the “public.” As Berry writes in “Sex, Economy, Freedom, & Community,” “As I understand the term, public means simply all the people, apart from any personal responsibility or belonging… A community, unlike a public, has to do first of all with belonging; it is a group of people who belong to one another and to their place.” The difference therefore between what we might call “public health” and “community health” is therefore all the difference in the world. One is dealing with the reality of people and their loves often made visible through story; the other is distracted by abstraction often made possible through aggregate statistics. Berry challenges us to imagine how the trajectory of public health (statistics, credentials programs, technical reports and all) must find its home within concrete communities. For it is only a community which can claim, in the words of Hall, that “when one person has diabetes, … their community has diabetes.” If public health creates the conditions in which that claim is made more tangible, it has done its work well.
Likewise, it is common for public health to consider the causes of disease through the “socioecological framework,” which distinguishes the “five levels” which contribute to health: individual, interpersonal, organizational, community, society. In response to this framework, Berry would likely say that it’s simply all the same thing, much as he affirms the English agriculturist Sir Albert Howard’s observation that “the whole problem of health in soil, plant, animal, and man [is] one great subject.” To insist that each of these layers is distinct—like the folds of an onion—is to risk corrupting what is ultimately a deeper unity. As Berry described in “The Body and the Earth,” “For no matter the distinctions we draw between body and soul, body and earth, ourselves and others—the connections, the dependences, the identities remain.” This is why health is not, contrary to the speculative hopes of folks like Christopher Boorse, fully reducible to the statistical normality of an individual’s biological functioning, but must also be seen as membership within the network of a whole community. This whole-of-community approach is, as one just example, practically documented in RAND’s 2023 report on “America’s Opioid Ecosystem,” which details over the course of 600 pages how “confronting the [opioid] crisis is not just about better pain management or treatment for opioid use disorder,” but must extend to change within the dozens of different interacting and interconnected systems which contribute to and are impacted by an individual’s opioid dependency (employment, food, criminal legal system, families, etc.).
Along with his insistence on the “wholeness” of health, Berry’s most important message for public health might very well be his critique of public health as a specialized and independent profession. Berry goes so far as to write that “It is therefore absurd to approach the subject of health piecemeal with a departmentalized band of specialists. A medical doctor uninterested in nutrition, in agriculture, in the wholesomeness of mind and spirit is as absurd as a farmer who is uninterested in health. Our fragmentation of this subject cannot be our cure, because it is our disease.” We see this as a direct challenge for us to get our heads out of our offices, textbooks, and computer models, and get to know the people and ideas which exist far away from the traditional halls of the health departments or public health academia: theologians, artists, urban planners, and, of course, farmers.
Leaving the desk to embody neighborliness would itself be a powerful corrective to the field. During the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines in the spring of 2021, tribal communities in the eastern part of our state were among the least vaccinated, and we were contacted to assist with education about these vaccines given the abundant misinformation and skepticism. Over the past five years, the resulting engagement—not with vaccine hesitancy in the abstract, but with Greg and Isabell and Nadine and so many others—has grown into relationships that deepen by the season. Leaving our offices not only led to vaccine Q&As, but to church homecomings, coffee shop conversations about grief, Pow Wow celebrations, talking circles, and a late-night text to see if “you and your students might be able to come help us harvest the sorghum.” The weather meant they needed to do a lot of work in a little bit of time and they reached out. Not to a professional or an expert, but to a neighbor. As a field, the public health profession might do well to ask honest questions about whether our public health work puts us in the kind of relationships in which this neighborliness is even possible.
In the words of the Institute of Medicine’s landmark 1988 report on The Future of Public Health, the best of public health will always be “what we as a society do collectively to assure the conditions in which people can be healthy.” Berry’s ecological, holistic vision of health and community constantly brings us back to this basic reality. In the best of worlds, we should all be seen and celebrated in the work of public health, as we all have responsibilities to care for ourselves, others, and the world in which we dwell in ways which contribute to our health. As Berry argues in “The Body and the Earth,” an attempt to go about the work of public health as an independent profession cannot help but tend towards control and isolation: “To try to heal the body alone is to collaborate in the destruction of the body. Healing is impossible in loneliness; it is the opposite of loneliness. Conviviality is healing.” This is a powerful lesson for a profession which is experiencing all-time low levels of trust.
As a case in point, last year one of us served as the keynote speaker for a public health conference in Iowa. The state’s public health association was celebrating the 100th anniversary of its first convening. As part of the celebration, the expo displayed records from the first meetings. These records evidenced the participation of physicians and nurses and pharmacists, but also farmers and firefighters and civic leaders. During one of the sessions, a participant noted the distance created between public health and its public by simply asking, “When is the last time you were at a public health conference with farmers and firemen?” In the spirit of this questioner, Berry’s writings make us wonder why there are so many summits, panels, and convenings aimed at public health without the expertise of local farmers—some of the foremost experts in creating conditions of vitality—as well as many other members of society whose labor contributes to the “conditions in which people can be healthy.”
Berry’s writings ultimately strike at the fundamental purpose of our profession. Consider how there is, in fact, no greater public justification for the work of public health than the extension of life expectancy in the modern era. According to the CDC, environmental improvements throughout the twentieth century contributed to a 29.2-year increase in life expectancy in the United States, and “25 years of this gain are attributable to advances in public health.” Not only would Berry challenge such a wholesale attribution of this improvement to a single group of specialists, but he would also remind us that discussing human life expectancy without considering the quality of the years added is inherently technocratic—as if the only measure of health were the raw number of years we remain alive: “The statistics of life expectancy are favorites of the industrial apologists, because they are perhaps the hardest to argue with. Nevertheless, this emphasis on longevity is an excellent example of the way the isolated aims of the industrial mind reduce and distort human life, and also the way statistics corrupt the truth.” The goal of simply adding more years to life must be seriously challenged if those years are spent in loneliness and isolation, as is increasingly the case for the elderly members of our population and many others besides. Rather than narrowly seeking to extend average life expectancy through policies and programs—including those vulnerable to eugenic motives—Berry challenges us to ensure that longer lives can be more meaningfully lived in community wherein “prolonged life is virtuous [and] … satisfactory.” In response to the grand ambitions of public health officials who seek to extend life expectancy—thousands of pages of reports, analyses, and plans for how the body can be kept alive—Berry reminds us to “think little,” for “Thinking Big has led us to the two biggest and cheapest political dodges of our time: plan-making and lawmaking.” In thinking little, we better see how so much of how we care for the health of others and our environment begins not with the construction of new organizations but with a conversion of our own hearts, and must therefore happen within a community in which that conversion is encouraged and sustained over the long haul.
In fact, we believe Berry offers us an even more expansive vision for the purpose of public health than merely the extension of quality life-years. If health is characterized by wholeness, then the task of any health professional is to facilitate the reunion of two or more parts that belong together within the whole. Again, from “The Body and the Earth,” “Healing … complicates the system by opening and restoring connections among the various parts—in this way restoring the ultimate simplicity of their union.” Critically, when done correctly, healing ultimately enables the body to restore its strength to a kind of homeostasis—its own ability to maintain balance amidst changing environments and demands. It is through this process that, as Berry writes, that “[the body] begins to live again by its own powers and instincts, to the extent that it can do so … it goes free of drugs and mechanical helps. Its appetites return. It relishes food and rest. The patient is restored to family and friends, home and community and work.” For Berry, to heal the body is to return it to itself.
How might such an account inspire the public health professional? If healing the body implies returning it to a state in which it “[lives] again by its own powers” and is no longer dependent on “drugs and mechanical helps,” perhaps Berry would characterize the work of public health as creating the conditions in which a community is no longer dependent on an external, technical apparatus to sustain its own being in the world. If healing returns the body to itself, then Berry’s vision of public health might very well be to return the community to itself.
We believe this Berry-inspired vocation resonates with the best of public health already being done in many places across the country. Consider the recent winners of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s Culture of Health Prize. Community members in the city of Trenton, New Jersey developed the “Trenton Restorative Street Team” to implement various restorative justice practices, such as community circles and community-led first responders. Citizens from Green Bay, Wisconsin, developed localized evaluation tools to measure community well-being, leading to the declaration of racism as a public health issue; through the “cultivating Community” project, others in the city have developed initiatives to improve cultural connections to food through prioritizing sourcing food from local farmers of various ethnic minorities. Individuals in Juneau, Alaska are advancing dialogues on racial equity and reviving indigenous culture through traditional healing practices. Those in the Lower Eastern Shore, Maryland, and Sussex County, Delaware, have engaged citizen scientists to conduct community-owned research regarding environmental contamination. Community members in Milwaukee County, Wisconsin are working toward the development of mixed-use housing, along with a more pedestrian-friendly area of downtown Milwaukee. Those in Moloka’i, Hawaii are working towards the restoration of their shoreline from invasive macroalgae which is threatening nearshore fisheries, while others are developing Mobile Markets to expand access to locally sourced produce throughout the island. In Sacramento, California, a local nonprofit has centered the lived experience of youth in the juvenile justice system, as well as developed job training programs for young people leaving the foster care system. And Tribes in the Great Lakes Region are reestablishing traditional trade routes to generate economic pathways for tribal members to produce traditional foods and products. While the manifestation varies widely, each of these communities is, in their own way, healing their communities by healing the relationships within those communities and thereby restoring life and power to that community. To advocate for community-based policing, local measures of well-being, indigenous practices, pedestrian-friendly streets, the value of lived experience, and the economic viability of local producers is, at bottom we believe, to attempt to return the community to itself through the reintegration of whole persons and their relationships with others into the everyday practices of life. Once more, from “The Body and the Earth,” “Only by restoring the broken connections can we be healed. Connection is health. And what our society does its best to disguise from us is how ordinary, how commonly attainable, health is.”
As it happens, we recently published a reflection on “Artificial Intelligence and the Purposes of Public Health,” in which we principally draw from Berry’s communal vision of the good life to challenge what we believe are dangerous temptations which exist at the intersection of public health and artificial intelligence (AI). There are simply too many parallels between his haunting question, “Is the obsolescence of human beings now our social goal?” and the implicit goal of certain versions of public health technocracy which AI will further enable.
In this age of runaway technological acceleration, we do indeed need Berry right now. We’re grateful that he leaves us with a treasury of writings and, more importantly, a community of friends who wish to bring those writings to life.
Thank you, Berry, for directing us toward “our real work” of healing. May you rest in peace and rise in Glory, and even “dance to the fiddle” while doing so.
References








2 comments
Russell Arben Fox
THANK YOU, Drs. Johnson and Tillman. This is the real MAHA–situating public health “within concrete communities,” through participatory work, shared labor, and emergent practices, with “physicians and nurses and pharmacists, but also farmers and firefighters and civic leaders” all talking about local food and balanced medical interventions and general wholeness, and not top-down ranting and rumor-mongering about vaccines or microplastics or contrails, all of which is just another version of the exact same top-down imposition of alienating expert knowledge that gave rise to the rampant and damaging skepticism which the health grifters all around us (most definitely including the paranoid minds currently leading the HHS) benefit from. May your tribe increase!
Deborah Black
It strikes me that your work of convincing the Native American population to succumb to the pressure to vaccinate is a dangerous and even covert, let alone deceitful use of the fine words of Wendell Berry.
I think Wendell Berry would not be interested in using his wholesome model of community healing to be used in such a nefarious manner that supports big Pharma rather than supporting original healing methods that truly are convivial, rather than relying on false statistics as to what improves the human condition.
Unfortunately this isn’t the first time Front Porch Republic props up wolves in sheep’s clothing.
It’s pretty clear this is a campaign that includes the current administration as they announce the expansion of community centers in rural areas while continuing to profit themselves off of the earnings of both the medical and pharmaceutical companies.