The New “Freedom”

And as interior designers intone almost every hour on HGTV, confused places – places that are cluttered or serve contradictory purposes – inevitably confuse the people who inhabit them.  Places that are confused make people frenetic, puzzled, and overwhelmed. Cluttered places create more clutter, inside and out.

Especially in my students, I see how hard it is for contemporary Americans to focus on working or writing for long blocks of time. The temptation to make a couple of clicks and check e-mail, or do some instant messaging, or shop for shoes, is constantly weighing on them. My own students are young people – I love my students! hi, students! – who on the whole do not lack for self-control. In the extensive sorting and testing and judging process that now comprises American education, they have excelled. They have excelled in this system thanks to some luck, of course, but also thanks to the habit of making good choices and exercising some degree of self-restraint.

But they – and we – simply inhabit a world which makes self-control a constant challenge. Every second, at a computer, you can choose do to something else. And every second, you can actualize that choice. You have to be choosing every moment.

One of the things that a good place can do is signal to us, somewhere in our minds, that there is a particular purpose at hand (and that it is appropriate to temporarily put other concerns aside). A church, as a place, signals that it is time for prayer and reflection — and not a time for buying a new shower curtain. A restaurant signals that it is time to eat — and not a time to find out what your ex-boyfriend looks like these days.  Good places, in other words, can help focus us on a task and give us a sense of order in the moment.

But when you look at a computer, you are inhabiting a place which does not give you any kind of calming or orienting signal. You are inhabiting a place where anything is possible. You might even call it “utopic” in Thomas More’s wry sense: a seemingly good or perfect place which is really no place at all. Computers displace us. They displace us physically – they enable us to talk to anyone, anywhere, and so forth – but they also displace us emotionally and intellectually. They confuse and distract us.

So I’m glad that Freedom exists, even if I’m not glad that it has to exist. In a circumstance that conspires to disorient us at every moment, Freedom is a kind of compass, enabling us to help ourselves get to the places where we want to go. After all, when you try to go all directions at once, you end up not going anywhere at all.

Page 2 of 2 | Previous page

8 comments on this post.
  1. Anthony:

    I’m going to quote this just because I can: “Computers displace us. They displace us physically – they enable us to talk to anyone, anywhere, and so forth – but they also displace us emotionally and intellectually.”

    A technical note: programs like Freedom have existed for some time.

  2. Bill:

    Ah, the irony. I read this article in its entirety because I had hit an obstacle at work, and wanted to put off finding a solution. So I jumped into Google Reader and checked the latest headlines.

    Freedom, the software is a useful tool. It’s useful in the way that some dim bulbs seem to think poverty is useful: necessity produces a certain degree of virtue (thrift, for example, or the “common spirit” of the Depression). Freedom, however, lets you have your luxury and eat it productively. Or something like that.

  3. Esmeralda_Pearl:

    Susan….Just amazing! What will “they” think of next?

    Even us “oldsters” have become more and more “addicted” to the internet. Here I sit, on a beautiful day, reading blogs instead of being outdoors!

    See you later! I’ve got do some weeding in the garden! :)

  4. Russell Arben Fox:

    I can’t believe nobody has put this link up yet.

  5. jmgregory:

    Wow, thank you for saying what I’ve been trying to verbalize for a long time. What an interesting paradox, though it has been well-documented, that freedom requires restrictions.

    If your job requires you to have constant internet access (for instance, to check your e-mail), another option out there is a Firefox plugin called LeechBlock, which lets you block the sites you spend the most time on, or limit them to a certain amount of time per day, or certain periods of the day. Sadly, I may have to add FPR to my list soon.

    Dropping our internet service at home has made for a huge improvement in our family life, but it has also created the problem that the internet access at work must be used for shopping, personal communication, etc. Then again, I was already using it for those things. It is almost as if I need two offices: one that has internet access, and one that does not.

  6. Contemporary Furniture:

    Is there more deeper definition of freedom?

  7. The Virtual Meeting Coach:

    Love this post, love the image you’ve used and wonder where it came from. I want to use it to illustrate another perspective on freedom.

  8. Mahmoud Ibrahim:

    Egypt is longing for freedom

Leave a comment