An FPR Symposium: Shop Class as Soul Craft, by Matthew Crawford
During the course of this entire week, FPR will devote its main pages to a symposium on the recent book Shop Class as Soul Craft by Matthew Crawford. The book has been widely discussed in the pages and on the airwaves of a number of major media outlets, and clearly has struck a chord with contemporary readers concerned about the trajectory of the modern American workplace away from knowing how to do things instead toward a dominant role of the kind of work done by what Robert Reich called “symbolic analysts.” Coming at a time of economic crisis, an increased interest (and necessity) of repairing our own stuff and growing our own food, and growing concern about the viability of an economic system based upon outsourcing and offshoring, the book is a timely reminder that certain kinds of work are always necessary, and further, that many of the manual trades possess an inherently integrative and purposive function that are often lacking in the sorts of deracinated jobs in many contemporary blue- and white-collar workplaces. It is a repudiation of much of the ideology that underlies modern globalization and elite and academic assumptions about the superiority of office work over hand craft.
In the book, Matt Crawford argues on behalf of the virtues of crafts – those forms of work that require skill of hands, a storehouse of knowledge and experience, patience, improvisational ability, and creativity. His book is a seering indictment of the alienation and deforming nature of much of what constitutes modern work, whether those “manual” jobs that tend to be modeled on mass-production models of assembly line, or “brain” work that more often than not results in workplaces that resemble “The Office” or “Dilbert.” He argues fiercely against the notion that there ought to be a conceptual separation between “manual” and “mental” work, noting that the crafts require a high degree of thought and creativity. The book argues for a reconsideration of many modern assumptions about the superiority of certain kinds of educational tracks and life paths, and ably points out that many modern office jobs are just as intellectually deadening as the assembly line jobs that once required 93 job offers for every one position being filled. There was a time when men and women had a sense of the dignity of work that most people refused to remain in a job that degraded and alienated its holder. Now, Crawford suggests, many regard such work (especially its white collar iterations) as a badge of success.
Matt brings a great deal of personal authority and experience to the basic argument of his book: he grew up working as an electrician and currently owns a motorcycle repair shop in Richmond, VA, but also holds a Ph.D. in political philosophy from the University of Chicago and a fellowship in the Institute for Advanced Studies in Culture at the University of Virginia. In this book he brings together the two worlds that are often sundered by a modern form of Gnosticism, the privileging of the work of mind over the work of hands. The book is highly readable – an appealing combination of serious philosophical reflection and often uproarious personal anecdotes. For those readers who have not yet read the book, but are interested in learning more of its basic argument in the course of reading the various assessments of the book on offer here this week, we recommend (in addition to reading the book itself) this early version of the book’s argument - an essay that first appeared in the fine journal The New Atlantis – and this excerpt from the book that appeared in the pages of the New York Times Magazine.
I hope readers will enjoy a week of sustained attention to a single book – and we’ll return to “our regular programming” next week.
Patrick Deneen, Symposium Editor
Monday’s Posts: Rod Dreher and Samuel Goldman
Tuesday’s Posts: Susan McWilliams and Jason Peters
Wednesday’s Posts: Patrick Deneen and Matt Feeney
Thursday’s Posts: Mark Mitchell and Conor Williams
Friday’s Posts: Mark Shiffman and Russell Arben Fox
Related posts:
- Shop Class as Radio Show Matthew Crawford – political philosopher and motorcycle repairman – has...
- A Short Riff on ‘Spiritedness’ in Matt Crawford’s “Shop Class as Soulcraft” ROCK ISLAND, IL By the time we retired the five-unit...
- Shop Class and the Romantic Mode of Politics It goes without saying that Matthew Crawford’s Shop Class as...
- Gumbo as Soul Craft When I read “Shop Class As Soulcraft,” I initially felt...
- In Other Shops… Joe Carter weighs in at First Things with a set...
The good news is that our industrial model is headed toward a reuniting of head and hands. The Sloan model of mass production industry will probably be replaced by the kind of networked production that prevails in Italy’s Emilia-Romagna region: integrating power machinery into craft production, using general-purpose machines to switch frequently between small batches of different products. And as Johann Soderberg pointed out, the computer is the ultimate artisan’s tool–a general-purpose machine controlled by a flexible, skilled operator and adaptable to a wide variety of purposes. And that artisan’s tool is well on the way toward destroying the corporate dinosaurs of the old proprietary content industries–music, software, publishing, etc.
(cross comment in Rod Dreher’s blog regarding his post about a Papal thanks to carpenters)
I wonder what P. Deneen, who is both a Catholic and praises Ancient Greece, thinks about this statement by the Pope:
“In the Greek world, intellectual work alone was considered worthy of a free man. Manual work was left to slaves.
The biblical religion is quite different…”
I believe that what his majesty the Pope calls “Greek world” was coined by several city-states and had different views regarding “labour and trade”:
- in Sparta, all work was despised and no citizen was allowed to engage in it; this was the result of they military situation and control of population that outnumbered the citizens
- in Athens, they were strongly attached to the idea of democracy and freedom, so that farmers and mechanics were permitted citizen status and voting rights
Pericles declared during his famous “Funeral Oration”, that “our ordinary citizens, thought occupied with the pursuits of industry are still fair judges of public matters” (Thucydides 1934, 2:38)
Source is “The Concept of Work” by Herbert Applebaum, available in Google Books.
I always like watching American Chopper. Imagine how pathetic I am, it’s enjoyable to watch other people make neat stuff while I waste away as a Weberian technocrat.
[...] laborers and the word workers is almost insurmountable. For example, my favorite localists over at Front Porch Republic have dedicated an entire week(!) to Crawford’s book. Yet their discussions are not likely to [...]
Goodness gracious, as my grandmother used to say. That this discussion could come up in my lifetime shows how quickly we have slid downhill. Shop classes were a joke in my school years; we already knew how to do all that stuff. I never mastered carburetors, but all my friends could take a tractor, truck or car apart and put it back together by the age of fourteen. We all learned crafts. I remember Bill Buckley writing somewhere that his father insisted that each of his ten children learn to type and to play a musical instrument. Among the upper classes, the economy was already a mystical thing.
The order of Creation, at its most basic, requires us to grow things, make things, and fix things. Jesus spent many years making things before his ministry. There is no better model. For about 48 years now (1961 and the cult of the Kennedys is a pretty good dot spot) we in this declining country have been growing, making, and fixing less and less. And as we have put the teaching of such matters into public educational institutions, at whatever level, it gets only worse.
All of my students can text message; not one can grow a tomato.
[...] the post, Carter also refers to a week-long symposium about the book on the Front Porch Republic blog. You can read a variety of perspectives there. You’ll find lots of other [...]
[...] a DIY tag is attached to interesting projects that would help me improve from hopeless handyman to soul crafter (to use Matt Crawford’s lingo). I budget an hour or two over the weekend to try my hand at [...]
[...] up on some items in my Google reader that I wanted to take a look at. Looks like last week the Front Porch Republic did a big thing on Matthew Crawford’s Shop Class as Soulcraft, which I mentioned here in [...]
The ancient Jews taught that one should be able to use his hands and his mind. Our society has drifted away from respecting those who can fix things and glorifying those who work in a virtual world of finance. I found woodshop in grade school – yes, grade school – to be the greatest of classes.
[...] 13, 2009 · Leave a Comment Shop Class as Soulcraft is generating lots of talk, as it should. It is one of those books that I keep thinking about long after I finished [...]
[...] mixed reaction to Matthew Crawford’s Shop Class as Soulcraft–which, of course, we spent a whole week talking about here–Tim and I got into a bit of an exchange, during which he sharpened his [...]
Leave your response!
From the Porch:
the FPR blogwith 1 Comment
I’m betting at least some readers of this site were there; after all, he speaks of his fellow watchers as “all folks with Front Porch Republic sympathies.” I wish I could have joined him; it sounds like the conversation was…
with No Comments
The snow started here in the D.C. area around noon on Friday. By nightfall most everything outside lay covered by a deep blanket of white, and in the darkness one could hear the cracking of branches and even entire trees…
with 6 Comments
Can national pride create national blind spots?
with 1 Comment
Is happiness found in fan-dom?
with 30 Comments
The future of the Tea Party is uncertain, but there are interesting possibilities.
with 3 Comments
Why not stand on the shoulders of the Kindle?
with 3 Comments
My own views would fall most accurately along the continuum between anarcho-capitalist and conservative-traditionalist…
with 9 Comments
Even as he denounces the conservative justices for activism and for creating “legislation” from the bench, as well as the general conservative movement for a “double standard without apology” . . . he fails to note the double-standard that he (and others on the Left) are employing in their demands for judicial modesty.
with 3 Comments
Here’s a sign of the times: if you’re worried about what all these digital and internet technologies are going to do to books, you can join a movement to signal your support of books (and other pen-and-inked things).
Here’s what really makes that a sign of the times: the movement is online.
with 7 Comments
Let’s just go all the way, folks.
Random Post
My father played for the Philadelphia Eagles. He didn’t particularly want to: In 1933, 1934, and 1935 the Eagles were a new “franchise” in the National Football League and not like…
Current Hits
Most Commented this Week
all time